Methodology
How we select, classify and review the tools we cover.
This page explains how we build directory profiles, comparisons and educational tools, so readers can judge the reliability of what we publish.
How tools are selected
We profile tools that are publicly available, actively referenced by practitioners or in technical communities, and relevant to research, analytics or systematic trading. Vendors cannot pay for inclusion. We may decline to profile products whose public materials make performance promises we consider misleading.
What each profile field means
| Field | Definition |
|---|---|
| Discipline | The primary job the tool performs in a trading workflow (e.g. backtesting, execution, analytics). |
| Code access | Whether source code is publicly available under an open-source licence. “Open-source engine” means the core is open while hosted services are not. |
| Intended autonomy | Research tool: does not trade. Human-in-the-loop: provides information; a person decides. Semi-automated: automates analysis or alerts; a person executes. Fully automated execution: can place orders without per-trade human approval. |
| Asset coverage | Markets the tool is documented to support. |
| Strengths / limitations | Editorial assessment based on documentation, public code and, where possible, hands-on use. |
Why we do not score, rank or price tools
Trading outcomes depend on the user, strategy, market and period. No editorial team can verify that one tool produces better results than another, so numerical ratings would imply a precision we do not have. We also omit prices, which change frequently and would turn editorial pages into shopping pages.
Sources
- Official documentation and websites of each project or vendor
- Public code repositories and release notes
- Regulatory filings and public statements, where relevant
- Hands-on use of free tiers or open-source code, where available
Review cycle
Profiles are reviewed at least twice a year and whenever we learn of a material change. Each profile shows its last review date. Comparisons and articles carry their publication date; substantive updates are logged on our Corrections page.
Interactive tools
Our calculators implement standard, published formulas. Each tool page states the formula used and its limitations. Calculations run entirely in the reader's browser and no inputs are collected.
Use of AI
As described in our Editorial Policy, AI tools may assist research and editing, but every published page is reviewed by a human editor who is accountable for its accuracy.